Rawhide Vs Bully Sticks: What Is The Difference

Rawhide Vs Bully Sticks: What Is The Difference

Apr 25, 2023Muhammad Usman

Are you confused about whether to choose rawhide or bully sticks for your furry friend? Our blog post has got you covered! Learn about the key differences between these popular dog treats and discover which one might be the best fit for your pup's needs. Read now and make an informed decision for your beloved pet!

As a pet owner, you want to ensure that your furry friend has a happy and healthy life. This includes providing them with the best food and treats possible.

So when it comes to dog treats, two of the most popular options are bully sticks and rawhide bones. 

While both are marketed as healthy and enjoyable treats for dogs, there are some key differences between the two.

Did you know which one is the best choice for your pup?

In this article, we will explore the benefits and drawbacks of both bully sticks and rawhide. We hope this will help you in making an informed decision about what to feed your four-legged friend.

Importance Of Providing Healthy And Enjoyable Treats For Dogs

Before diving into what treat is good for your dog and what is not, it is important to note that giving your pet healthy and yummy treats is really important! 

Just like how people enjoy eating delicious food, pets also love having tasty treats to munch on. But it's not just about the taste alone- treats can also give your pet important vitamins and minerals to keep them healthy.

Providing healthy and enjoyable treats for pets is essential for several reasons:

Promotes Good Health:

Just like humans, dogs need a balanced diet to maintain good health. Providing healthy treats can help to supplement their diet and provide additional nutrients that may be missing in their regular food. Healthy treats also help to improve your dog’s immune system and keep him active and healthy.

Prevents Obesity:

Overfeeding your dog with high-calorie treats can lead to obesity, which can cause several health problems. Providing healthy and low-calorie treats can help to prevent obesity in pets and keep them at a healthy weight.

Strengthens The Bond Between Dog And Owner:

Offering treats is a great way to bond with pets and show them love and affection. When the treats are healthy and enjoyable, it reinforces positive behavior and encourages good habits.

Reduces Stress And Anxiety:

Providing treats can help to reduce stress and anxiety in dogs, especially during stressful situations like thunderstorms, fireworks, or vet visits. The act of receiving a treat can help to distract them from their fears and make them feel more comfortable.

Improves Dental Health:

Certain treats, such as dental chews, can help to improve the dental health of dogs by removing tartar and plaque from their teeth. This can prevent dental problems and keep their teeth and gums healthy.

Therefore, choosing healthy and enjoyable treats for your dog is essential for his overall health and well-being. So, it's important to choose treats that not only taste good but also have good ingredients that will help keep your pet strong and healthy.

Moreover, it is also important to choose treats that are appropriate for your dog's age, size, and health needs and avoid overfeeding or giving treats that may be harmful to it.

Rawhide Vs Bully Sticks - What is What?

Rawhide chews and bully sticks are popular treatment options for dogs, but they differ. In this comparison, we'll explore the ingredients, benefits, and potential risks of each to help you decide which treat is best for your furry friend.

What is Rawhide?

Rawhide is a famous dog chew made from the inner layer of cattle hides, especially cow or horse. The hides are cleaned, stretched, and dried to create a tough and chewy texture that many dogs enjoy. 

Rawhide dog chews are manufactured in different shapes like bones, twists, or rolls. Moreover, they come in a variety of sizes to accommodate different breeds and ages of dogs.

Rawhide chews can be a great way to satisfy a dog's natural chewing instincts and can also provide some dental benefits including helping to clean teeth and massage gums. 

How Is Rawhide Made?

The process of making rawhide chews begins with the processing of cattle hides. It Is important to note that the rawhide is made from the inner side of the hide instead of the outer side.

The hides are first cleaned to remove any dirt, debris, or fat. Then, the hides are soaked in a solution of water and either sodium sulfide or lime for several hours to help loosen the hair and flesh from the hide.

After preparing the skin, it goes through a special bath in hydrogen peroxide. This is to make sure all the germs and bacteria are gone. It also makes the tissue look a white-yellow color that's easy to recognize.

Once the hair and flesh have been removed, the inner side of the hides are rinsed thoroughly and stretched to remove any wrinkles or bumps. Then, the hides are cut into various shapes, such as bones or twists, and left to dry in the sun or in a special oven for several days.

It's important to note that some rawhide bones may be treated with additional chemicals or preservatives to enhance their flavor or extend their shelf life. 

However, these additives can sometimes cause digestive issues or allergic reactions in some dogs, so it's important to choose high-quality rawhide chews that are free from harmful additives.

During the drying process, the hides become hard and stiff, creating the characteristic tough and chewy texture of rawhide chews. At this point, the chews can be packaged and sold to pet stores and other retailers.

Also, note that some rawhide chews may be treated with bleach or other chemicals to create a whiter appearance, but this can also be harmful to dogs if ingested in large quantities.

Benefits of Rawhide?

Rawhide treats can have some benefits for dogs when given in moderation and under supervision. Here are a few benefits of rawhide chew treats:

Chewing benefits: Chewing on rawhide can help satisfy a dog's natural urge to chew and can also help clean their teeth and massage their gums, which promotes healthy dental hygiene.

Mental stimulation: Rawhide Treat can provide mental stimulation for dogs and help relieve stress or anxiety.

Long-lasting: Rawhide chews are typically durable and can provide a long-lasting chew experience for dogs-A useful feature for high-energy or aggressive chewers.

Affordable: These treats are often more affordable than other types of dog treats, which makes them a good option for dog owners on a budget.

Drawback Of Rawhides

While rawhide treats can have some benefits for dogs, there are also some potential drawbacks that pet owners should be aware of. Here are a few:

Additives and chemicals: Most rawhide chews these days contain harmful additives or chemicals, like bleach or formaldehyde, which are harmful to dogs if ingested in large quantities. This is the biggest health issue with rawhide chews for dogs and the reason we dont recommend it for your dog in the first place.

Digestive issues: Rawhide bones are difficult for some dogs to digest. More often if the dog swallows large pieces or if it consumes too much at once. This can lead to digestive issues such as vomiting, diarrhea, or constipation.

Choking hazard: Rawhide chews can also pose a choking hazard for some dogs. Especially if they try to swallow large pieces or if the chew becomes soft and can be broken apart easily.

Quality control: Rawhide chews can vary widely in quality, and some may be made from lower-quality hides that are more likely to break apart or cause digestive and choking issues. 

Bully Sticks

Bully sticks are some of the best dog treats that come from beef. They are long and thin and look like sticks. Bully sticks are made by drying bull penises. Yes, you read it right. It might sound kind of strange but don't worry, they are perfectly safe for dogs to eat!

Bully sticks are a good treat for dogs because they are high in protein and low in fat. Protein helps to build and maintain strong muscles, and dogs need lots of it to stay healthy. The low-fat content also makes them a good option for dogs that need to lose weight.

Overall, if your dog enjoys bully sticks and is not allergic to beef, it can be a great treat to add to their diet. Just be sure to monitor your pet while they're chewing on them to make sure they're not eating too much or swallowing any large pieces.

How Are Bully Sticks Made?

Bully sticks are made from the penises of bulls. The process starts by removing the penis from the bull and washing it thoroughly to remove any bacteria or dirt. Then, the penis is stretched and twisted and left to dry for several days until it becomes hard and chewy.

After they are fully dried, the bully sticks are sorted and graded based on their size and quality. The highest quality bully sticks are made from the pizzle, or the part of the penis closest to the body, while lower quality sticks are made from the outer parts of the penis.

It's important to note that bully sticks are completely safe for dogs to eat, as they are thoroughly washed and sterilized during the production process. Some manufacturers also use additional cleaning methods, such as irradiation or high-pressure water, to ensure that the sticks are free from harmful bacteria.

Types and Shapes of Bully Sticks

Bully sticks come in various shapes to cater to different dog preferences and needs. 

Some of the common shapes of bully sticks are 

  • straight sticks, 
  • braided sticks, 
  • spiral sticks, 
  • rings, 
  • bars, 
  • and even pretzel shapes. 

Each shape has its own unique texture and chewing challenge for dogs. 

Some shapes like braided sticks and rings take longer to chew, making them perfect for dogs who like to take their time. 

Straight sticks and bars are great for dogs who are intense chewers and can go through treats quickly.

What are the nutritional benefits of Bully sticks?

Bully sticks are a great source of protein for dogs, which is essential for building and maintaining strong muscles. They also contain amino acids, which are important for overall health and well-being.

Another nutritional benefit of bully sticks as compared to rawhide bones is that they are low in fat, which makes them a great option for dogs that need to lose weight or maintain a healthy weight.

Here we want to mention that bully sticks from Foodiepaws are free from any harmful additives and preservatives that are commonly found in other dog treats. They are a natural and healthy option for dogs to enjoy as a tasty snack.

However, it's important to remember that bully sticks are also high in calories, so they should be given in moderation as part of a balanced diet.

12" Standard Bully Sticks - All Natural Premium Grade, Odor Free

Other Benefits Of Bully Sticks

Chewing benefits: Chewing on bully sticks helps satisfy a dog's natural urge to chew and can also help clean their teeth and massage their gums, which promotes healthy dental hygiene.

Mental stimulation: Bully sticks provide mental stimulation for dogs and help relieve stress or anxiety.

Long-lasting: Bully stick chews are durable and provide a long-lasting chew experience for your dog.

Affordable: These sticks are more affordable than many other types of treats thus making them a good option for dog owners.

What are the potential drawbacks of bully sticks?

Despite being safe dog treats, bully sticks might have some minor drawbacks that can be avoided by keeping a check on your dog.

Digestive Issues: Some dogs may experience digestive issues like vomiting or diarrhea, after eating bully sticks. This is due to the high protein content or the fact that they are made from animal parts. If given in moderation your dog will remain healthy and happy.

Choking Hazard: Some dogs may try to swallow pieces of the bully stick whole, which can pose a choking hazard. 

You can stop it to happen by supervising your dog while he is chewing on a bully stick to ensure that they are chewing it properly and not trying to swallow any large pieces.

Allergies: Some dogs may be allergic to beef, which is the main ingredient in bully sticks. If your dog has a history of food allergies or sensitivities, it's important to consult with your veterinarian before giving them bully sticks. 

Comparison Between Bully Sticks and Rawhide 

When deciding between bully sticks and rawhide treats for your dog, there are several factors to consider. Here are some of the key differences between the two types of treats:


One of the most important factors to consider when choosing a dog treat is safety. While both bully sticks and rawhide chews can pose choking hazards or cause digestive issues if consumed in large quantities, bully sticks are generally considered safer and easier to digest than rawhide chews. Bully sticks are the winner!

Nutritional value:

Bully sticks are a natural, high-protein treat that provides several health benefits for your dog. While rawhide chews on the other hand are low in nutritional value and may contain harmful additives or chemicals. Bully sticks are the winner!


Price is also a consideration for many pet owners, and there can be significant price differences between bully sticks and rawhide chews. Rawhide chews are often more affordable than bully sticks, but they also have lower nutritional value. While bully sticks are costly but completely justify their price. Rawhide chews take the lead!


For dogs that are aggressive chewers or need a long-lasting treat to keep them occupied, durability is another factor to consider when comparing treats. While both bully sticks and rawhide chews can be durable, bully sticks are generally considered to be longer-lasting and more resistant to breaking apart than rawhide chews. Bully sticks are the winner!


Finally, the treat's taste is important to consider, as some dogs may prefer one type of treat over the other. Bully sticks have a natural, meaty flavor that many dogs find appealing, while rawhide chews may be less palatable or have an artificial taste due to the manufacturing process. So in this competition, it depends.

Overall, when deciding between bully sticks and rawhide chews for your dog, it's important to consider your dog's individual needs and preferences, as well as the safety, nutritional value, price, durability, and taste of each type of treat.

6" Mega Bully Sticks - All Natural Premium Grade, Odor Free

Which Treat is Right for Your Dog?

With so many factors to consider, it can be difficult to determine which type of treat is best for your dog. Here are a few tips to help you make the right choice:

Consider your dog's individual needs: Every dog is different, and what works for one may not work for another. Consider your dog's age, size, breed, chewing habits, and any health conditions or dietary restrictions they may have when choosing a treat.

Choose high-quality treats: Whether you choose bully sticks or rawhide bones, it's important to choose high-quality treats that are made from natural, healthy ingredients and are free from harmful additives or chemicals.

Monitor your dog while they're chewing: No matter what type of treat you choose, always supervise your dog while he is chewing and take the treat away if it becomes too small or if your dog starts to choke or shows signs of digestive issues.

Offer a variety of treats: While bully sticks and rawhide chews can be great options for dogs, it's important to offer a variety of treats and toys to keep your dog engaged and stimulated. Consider offering other types of chews like antlers or bones, as well as puzzle toys or interactive toys that can help prevent boredom and provide mental stimulation.

Consult with your veterinarian: If you're unsure which type of treat is best for your dog, or if you have any concerns about your dog's diet or chewing habits, it's always a good idea to consult with your veterinarian for guidance and advice.


Do vets recommend bully sticks?

Yes, veterinarians recommend bully sticks as a healthy and safe dog treat for your dog. This is because bully sticks are different from other types of dog bones and stick-like treats because they do not splinter.

Thus eliminating the risk of broken pieces which may cause internal problems in your dog's body.

Do vets recommend rawhide?

Lots of vets say rawhide bones help keep your dog's teeth healthy, but at the same time, they also warn that there are some risks.

Some vets don't like the idea of giving dogs rawhide chew treats at all because there have been incidents where small broken pieces of rawhide have gotten stuck in dogs' throats or intestines.

What is the safest chew bone for dogs?

A bully stick is the safest chew bone for your dog. It is a healthy, digestible, and long-lasting dog treat. 


In our today’s comparison, Bully sticks are the winner.

Bully sticks are yummy and healthy treats for dogs! They're so delicious that all dogs, no matter their breed, age, or size, can enjoy chewing on them. Puppies can even eat them too, as long as they can chew hard food and treats by themselves. Just like for grown-up dogs, bully sticks give puppies lots of protein and help keep their teeth healthy.

Furthermore, bully sticks are amazing because they come in all kinds of shapes and sizes, so you can find one that your dog will love! 

If your dog loves to chew a lot and really chomps down hard, a braided bully stick might be perfect. But if your dog takes a long time to chew and savor their treats, a straight stick might be a better choice. And if you want to challenge your dog's brain while they chew, you could try a bully ring or another fun shape!

Lastly, they can keep your dog occupied for hours while they chew on them. Plus rest assured that bully sticks can stay fresh for up to three whole years!

6" Jumbo Bully Sticks - All Natural Premium Grade, Odor Free